You, Mixtab, Are No Google Reader

Mixtab Pro is available from Mixtab for US$3.99.

mix tab pro

With Google Reader’s demise, makers of software to subscribe to Really Simple Syndication feeds have hustled to fill the void.

The biggest winner in the RSS sweepstakes so far has been Feedly, which attracted a large portion of Google Reader’s orphans. Feedly has been so successful, in fact, that some RSS makers, like Reeder, are connecting to it, much as they plugged into Google Reader.

A more conventional way to attract Reader orphans is to allow them to import their feeds from the defunct service into a new reader. That’s the approach tried by Mixtab Pro, available for US$3.99 from the Mac App store.

At the end of last year, we reviewed the free version of Mixtab and were impressed with its visual audacity. Unlike some drab RSS readers, Mixtab uses a magazine-style approach to displaying the content of feeds — an approach pioneered by Flipboard, one of the first super apps for the iPad.


Miss List View

However visually arresting the magazine metaphor is, it has its drawbacks for hard core Reader users. That’s because it trades screen real estate for information.

Google Reader’s list view packs headlines from RSS articles on the screen. The view may have the all the allure of the agate on the stock pages of a newspaper, but it allows you to scan lots of information quickly.

With magazine layouts, articles have large headlines, photos and text that take up more room on a page. That’s sweeter for the eye, but it means fewer articles on a screen.

To some extent, the drawbacks to not having a list view can be offset by the program’s gesture support. With a trackpad, for example, you can slide your fingers across the pad to move left or right through groups of feeds.

When they work, the swipe gestures allow you to quickly flip through feed screens as fast as you would flip through the pages of a magazine. The problem is that you sometimes have to swipe two or three times before you can advance a screen, which can be annoying.

Clumsy Gestures

In the free version of Mixtab, there were arrows on the sides of the feed screens that could be clicked to advance them. Those don’t appear in Mixtab Pro, so if a swipe doesn’t succeed, you have no choice but to keep on swiping until it does.

It’s easy to understand why Mixtab’s developers removed the arrows — why do you need arrows if you can do something with gestures? — but in this case, the arrows would have provided some just-in-case redundancy that could make navigating in the app less vexing.

This latest version of Mixtab Pro was released just in time to be touted as an alternative to Google Reader. Unfortunately, we couldn’t get the RSS viewer to digest our Reader feeds.

Before our Reader account expired, we saved our feeds as instructed by Google. Reader exported all our account information into a Zip archive.

There’s a bunch of files in the archive, but the only important one is subscriptions.xml. That’s the equivalent of an OPML file, a format used for tree-style applications.

Import Choking

Mixtab choked on the XML file. It wouldn’t import it, generated a lengthy error message, and crashed.

The same thing occurred when we changed the file’s extension from XML to OPML — a trick that sometimes works with fussy RSS readers.

Since all our Google Reader feeds had been exported to Feedly, we tried exporting them into an OPML file created by that app.

Mixtab wouldn’t have anything to do with it. It flashed a message stating the file wasn’t a proper OPML file and then crashed.

So Mixtab Pro definitely didn’t make it as a Reader altrernative for us.

Attractive Feed Reader

Although Mixtab’s new gesture support and feed import features leave something to be desired, the app remains an attractive way to organize and view RSS feeds.

Feeds can be organized in “tabs,” which appear as tiles on the program’s home screen. Each tile contains a title for the group of feeds under it, along with a headline and graphic from a recent article in the feed stream.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s